Monday 23 August 2010

Owner’s Project Cost Management Approach: A Case Study of Underground Oil Storage Cavern Project in Vietnam

Over the past few decades, the Vietnam economy has grown very fast at the average rate of 7% per year. In line with the grow rate of the economy, the number of the projects with advance technology have been applied in Vietnam to meet the demand for new infrastructure in the modernized and industrialized period.With this kind of project, the project complexity shall be the great challenges to the organization performing it or the project owner.

As per local media, most giant projects first applied in Vietnam and performed by Vietnamese organization were delayed, cost overrun or not financially vital due to many reasons in which lacking appropriate cost management approach for those is really rampant.

Mr. Nguyen Sinh Khang made a study expecting that his report shall provide the respective project owner with some cost management approach.

The main objectives of his study were: (1) study the issues in cost management of construction project especially of underground oil storage cavern project in Vietnam; and (2) provide recommendations on how the problems can be managed and the frame work for owner’s project cost management approach covering whole span of the project from pre-contact stage to post-contract stage

Conclusions

For the project especially large-scale and complex project like underground oil storage cavern, the cost overrun shall occur due to three reasons such as: incomplete and inadequate drawings and specifications, the Owner’s change to project requirements and changes from Contractor. In spite of the efforts made by Owner, Owner’s Consultants and Contractors, there are considerable factors that made cost overrun inevitable and numbers of the factors are out of their responsibility and ability.

The followings are the Owner’s common factors that cause the problem in cost management of the project:
- Lack of management policy on report and control practices
- Improper estimating techniques and/or standards leading to impractical budget
- Fault sequence commencement and completion of activities and/or events
- Unexpected material cost escalation
- Poor scope of work definition or inadequate WBS (Work Breakdown Structure)
- Selecting Contractor with the lowest tender price
- Improper planning system resulting in ineffective action or cost
- Improper comparison of actual cost and planned cost
- Unexpected and unplanned technical issues
- Delays and disruption resulting prolongation cost

The conclusions for above mentioned problems shall be made as follows:

1. For Owner’s Cost management of pre-contract stage:
- The Owner normally selects Consultant or Contractor who proposes lowest bid regardless of experience, quality or expertise;
- Scope of work of Consultant or Contractor is poorly planned and defined;
- Low accuracy is inherent in the approved cost estimate;
- Tight approved budget is included in the overall scheme;
- Value engineering (VE) is not carried out during design phases especially in the initial phase of the project.

2. For Owner’s procurement strategies:
- Traditional method of procurement based on the clear separation of design and construction is deployed.
- Price-based, lump-sum and specification contract in which Contractor is required to estimate the quantities and subsequently to calculate tender sum based on the owner’s drawings and specifications is deployed.
- Risk access is not carried out for decision making especially in selection of project delivery system.

3. For Owner’s Cost management of post-contract stage:

Owner’s cost-management and monitoring procedure lacks the following characteristics:
- Cost is not forecasted before decision making
- Cost-recording system is not cost-effective to operate
- Actual cost is not subject to variance analysis
- Time and quality do not implicate in the cost

Change management – Valuing variations:
- The proper recording system for changes is not established and applied
- Traditional method of valuing variation which is based the valuation on the rates or prices specified in Bill of Quantity (BofQ) or schedule. Normally, those rates or prices were quoted at the time of tender.

Changes to the project arise due to:
- Inadequate briefing from the owner
- Inconsistent and late instruction from the Owners
- Incomplete design
- Lack of careful planning at design stage
- Lack of coordination of specialist design work
- Late clarification of complex details

Claim management:
- The delay claims on extension of time and cost of prolongation from Contractor is not solved effectively and in amicable way.

The Contractor often submits the claims due to the main following reasons :
- Inadequate time and planning before project commencement
- Inviting the tender on incomplete drawings
- Introducing extensive changes to the project
- Inadequate site investigation – deep basement; pilling, earthwork, tunneling or unforeseen ground condition
- Extensive changes to contract standard form
- Owner’s inference with the timing and sequence of construction

Recommendation for management improvement

For the project with the similar condition as one in the case study, the recommendation shall be made as follows:

1. Value-for-money mechanism should be in place to evaluate quality and price of the bid.

2. For any contract, the scope of work should be clearly defined.

3. Proper methods with the different degree of accuracy for each stage of the project shall be used.

4. The budget should be used positively to ensure that the design stays within the scope of the original scheme.

5. The factors to be considered during cost estimate shall be:
a. Land acquisition including legal fees
b. Owner’s organization cost allocated to the project
c . Site investigation
d. Insurances
e. Consultant’s fees including engineering
f. Equipment procurement and installation
g. Construction cost
h. Taxes
i. Contingencies and risks
j. Financing and legal cost

6. Comprehensive value management (VM) should be in place all the time.

7. Design and Build shall be deployed.

8. Price-based bill of quantity (BofQ) with milestone payments is applied.

9. Some risk management procedures should be in place all the time to access the risks so that unacceptable risks could be transferred to relevant Contractor or Insurer by contractual commitment. Who-life costing technique could be used where possible.

10. Costs should be forecasted before decisions are made to allow consideration of all possible actions

11. Cost-recording system should be simple and cost-effective to operate

12. Actual costs should be subject to variance analysis to determine the reasons for any deviation leading to cost overrun

13. The costs implication of time and quality should be incorporated into the decision making process

14. Parties should keep comprehensive and detail records of the factors relevant to the variation

15. Change consequences shall be mitigated by:
a. Setting up clear project objectives
b. Timely change instructions
c. Practically-completed design
d. Adequate planning at design stage
e. Adequate coordination of specialist design work
f. Timely clarification of complex details

16. The variation valuation procedure in which the parties need to have skilled negotiation and be prepared to adopt a give-and-take attitude in order to bring a satisfactory claim settlement.

17. Parties should keep comprehensive and detail records of the factors relevant to the variation.

18. The variation valuation procedure in which the parties need to have skilled negotiation and be prepared to adopt a give-and-take attitude in order to bring a satisfactory claim settlement.

19. Owner’s project management team should be equipped with knowledge of construction technology, construction law, term and conditions of the contract, contract administration, project-planning system and negotiation skill.

20. The following actions shall be required to avoid the claims:

a. Adequate plan made by competent Owner’s engineer and/or Consultant

b. Availability of verified and completed drawings and specifications prior to bid

c. Minimize and eliminate the unnecessary changes to the project;

d. Application of Value Engineering and/or Whole-life Costing and/or Risk Access techniques to analysis the changes to project;

e. Comprehensive site investigation in which the scope of site investigation shall be given by Consultant or Engineer who use site investigation data for engineering works;

f. Usage of relevant contract standard form set forth by recognized organization such as FIDIC, ICI ..etc.

g. Relevant Coordination procedure between Owner and Contractor.

His abstract is copied and posted.

ABSTRACT

As the same context of the projects which were first applied technology, construction methods or project size in the developed countries, the project of this kind or the likes in Vietnam cannot meet or exceed the stakeholder expectations due to many unforeseen reasons.

The role of the organization performing project of this kind of project is of great importance because its performance could bring the success or failure to these projects. In Vietnam, the regular phenomenon is that project planning and control of this kind of project is always under expectation due to the lack of project management competence from the organization performing project especially lack of appropriate cost management approach. Those shall have bad consequences to the direct or indirect stakeholders. Therefore, to be equipped with the most adaptable project planning and control system for this kind of project is required by and from the organization performing project and project team member also.

As mentioned above, the need of workable cost management approach for the project of this kind is critical. This report shall therefore address this development by underlining, prioritizing and specializing some aspects of owner’s construction project cost management approach and shall give some recommendations on or suggest some guidelines for this kind of project and specific project as descriptions in case study.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...


Tag: PM205A55. Let me share all of you about #5 Tips for Project Management Success,, I hope you enjoy it

1. Plan your day using time management techniques

As a project manager, time management skills are essential because you are dealing with a wide range of tasks that demand a quick turnaround time. Planning your day will go a long way in keeping you organized and increasing your productivity. Assist your task planning by using project management software which helps you track the work of you and your team.

If you are not very tech savvy, a simple to-do list can also be a great organizational tool. Prioritize your most important tasks by putting them at the top of the list and less important ones at the bottom. Having a visual plan of your daily tasks helps to keep you on track and aware of time.

Related post: Free ebook 104 secrets to become a great project manager

2. Include stakeholders in important project conversations

While you will have plenty of responsibilities regarding the project, don’t neglect your clients.

Good communication is essential is keeping both parties informed of project progression, curtailing scope creep, and apprised of changing requirements. Some clients may have different expectations when it comes to communication, so make sure to establish the frequency and type of communication (like emails, phone calls, and face-to-face conversations) at the beginning of your project.

Establishing communication expectations early helps alleviate stakeholder uncertainty about communication frequency and delivery.

3. Regularly communicate with your team

Daily team communication helps keep misunderstandings and unclear requirements under control. Keeping your team informed in every step of the project is essential to project management success.

For example, a study published by Procedia Technology found that good communication skills were the cornerstone of project management. The study examined over 300 “construction project managers, architects, construction managers, engineers and quantity surveyors” and their successes and failures on various construction projects.

4. Anticipate project setbacks

Even the best-laid plans often go awry.

Remember that even with a high amount of planning and attention to detail, your project may still encounter some challenges. Pay attention to complaints from stakeholders or colleagues, and other warning signs, like a missed deadline or cost overrun, that there may be a problem.

Preventing a crisis will keep your project running smoothly, save you a lot of time, and keep you, your team, and your stakeholders confident in progressing with the project.

Unfortunately not every complication can be avoided. Crisis management skills are essential for dealing with the unexpected. Project managers need to be flexible and pragmatic. Improvise and make sharp decisions when needed.

Related post: 92 free project management templates

5. Stay focused on the details

A common problem project managers encounter is having the project aims not aligned with the organization’s objectives. A great project manager will strategize a plan for the project to lead back to the overall success of the business.

Know your project’s scope by heart and avoid wandering outside of the project’s requirements. It’s too easy to get lost in minor details and forget what your focus is, so a well-planned project scope is essential for success.

And final, you should use KPI to measure effectiveness of the project, here are full list: 76 project management KPIs